Introduction
The health care scenario for
women, especially apropos reproductive health, is highly exploitative, with
extensive human rights violations. Women are treated as expendable entities.
Documented malpractice and possible cures
Malpractice has been observed and documented in the following medical
interventions relating to reproductive health:
I. Unsafe methods of abortion vis-a-vis the Medical Termination
of Pregnancy (MTP) Act.
The MTP Act provides the right to safe
abortion to women to prevent their exploitation at the hands of unscrupulous
abortionists. This professed purpose has failed. Presently unsafe (illegal)
abortions far exceed safe abortions, the ratio being 20: 1.
As a result, unsafe abortions today constitute the single largest cause of
pregnancy- related deaths. This is because the safety provisions of the MTP Act
are not implemented by the health authorities. Whilst this may be just another
example of the ubiquitous lack of monitoring by concerned authorities, a more
sinister explanation could be a deliberate ‘blind eye’ to achieve population
control through MTP.
The safety provisions in the MTP Act require approval and monitoring of a MTP
centre to ensure required surgical facilities and approval of the doctor’s
qualification, competence and training. Abortion after 12 weeks of pregnancy is
allowed only after consultation with two doctors and abortion is prohibited
after the 20th week of pregnancy.
Remedy: Ensuring facilities for safe abortion by strict implementation of the
provisions of the MTP Act and by taking legal action against health authorities
who fail to do so.
II. Unsafe contraceptives
The Intra Uterine
Device (IUD) is inserted without proper evaluation of the recipient woman for
genital tract infection. This can cause ascending infection leading to pelvic
inflammatory disease with painful menstrual periods, blockage of fallopian
tubes, resulting in sterility or tubal pregnancy and even peritonitis leading to
death.
Laparoscopic fallopian tube ligations are carried out improperly. This is due
to compromise of mandatory surgical norms by using unsterile laparoscopes or by
using unsafe procedures in place of those prescribed e. g. peritoneal
insufflation with atmospheric air in place of carbon dioxide. At times, a cycle
pump has been used for insufflation. As anticipated, the procedure fails and is
attended by an increased rate of complications as the result of these unhygienic
and unsafe practices. These lead to a high incidence of ectopic pregnancy and
catastrophic illness with high mortality even where surgical facilities are
available. The situation is worse in a rural setting. The estimated number of
such deaths due to faulty tubectomies is 500 for the 5 million ligations
presently done per year.
The use of contraceptive pills without prior tests to ensure normal liver
function constitutes a much greater hazard in our population as there is a high
prevalence of liver diseases such as viral hepatitis (3% of our population is in
the carrier stage of hepatitis- B while hepatitis- E is endemic) and amoebic
hepatitis is common in our country. Other factors such as compromised liver
function due to malnutrition, toxic damage from anti- tubercular drugs,
consumption of aflatoxin from ill preserved food grains, toxic pesticide
residues in food and water, and alcohol consumption increase the likelihood of
liver disease in our population.
Remedy:Peers in the profession practising ethical
medicine, especially those practicing obstetrics and gynaecology, should invoke
and insist upon exact adherence to medical ethics framed under the Medical
Council of India (MCI) Act.
III Prescription of unsafe drugs in pregnancy
There is a large number of drugs specifically contraindicated in pregnancy
and a still larger number of drugs that are considered unsafe in pregnancy and
should be avoided as far as possible. At present, drugs are prescribed
indiscreetly and indiscriminately unmindful of their safety in pregnancy. This
has caused a high rate of adverse outcomes in pregnancy such as miscarriages,
still births and congenital defects.
Remedy:Establishment of Drug Information Centres
to educate doctors and patients on the safety status of drugs in pregnancy.
IV Pesticide residues in food
These have an
especially deleterious effect on the pregnant mother and the child in the womb.
It is responsible for adverse pregnancy outcomes and congenital malformations
especially of the brain and spinal cord, more so in female foetuses.
Remedy:Awareness and education programmes with
stricter implementation of the Insecticide Act.
V Aggressive advertisement of drugs and self-
medication
Women are targets for aggressive advertisement of
drugs and tonics in the lay press as they are perceived to have concerns about
menstrual periods, figure- consciousness and the well being of their children.
The so- called uterine tonics, menstrual regulators, blood purifiers, slimming
remedies and brain and health tonics for children are heavily advertised and
encourage self- medication with drugs of doubtful and unproven efficacy, an
obviously fraudulent practice.
Remedy: Insistence on implementation of the
provisions of the Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable) Advertisement Act
that prohibits such advertisements. The offence is cognisable and the editor,
publisher and advertiser are all individually and collectively liable. Action
may also be initiated under the Press Council Act.
VI Advertisement of abortion
Abortion is legal
under the MTP Act but its advertisement is not permitted under the Drugs and
Magic Remedies (Objectionable) Advertisement Act. Soliciting patients is
unethical under the Medical Council Act. In spite of this, there is promotion
and propagation of abortion through agressive advertisements in the lay press,
railway compartments, buses and billboards. Perhaps the lack of the enforcement
of the ban on advertising is because of its tacit but illegal use as a
population control measure by the government.
Unsafe abortions with their attendant miseries and deaths are on the rise as
a result of this policy and exceed those in the pre- legalisation days.
VII Surgical excesses on women apropos pregnancy
There is a rising trend of Caesarean births, unnecessary
episiotomy as a routine in all first deliveries in hospitals. We also see rising
rates of hysterectomy at an early age.
Remedy: The Medical Council Act provides protection
against unnecessary surgical interventions. This should be invoked to penalise
wrong- doers.
VIII Experiments on women and methods of abortion for
contraceptive methods
Improperly planned, unapproved and
unethical experiments by the population control zealots amongst medical men are
presently widespread as reported in the Indian medical journals e. g. reports in
Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, India . For example, an abortion
paste called FETEX PASTE was approved and used on a mass scale killing hundreds
of women, till reports of the deaths led to its withdrawal .
IX Unregulated, assisted pregnancy
Frequent
genital tract infection and indiscriminate invasive interventions have resulted
in high prevalence of infertility amongst our women. Infertility carries a great
social stigma. Taking advantage of their emotional and social vulnerability, a
crop of self- proclaimed, mostly unqualified and untrained fertility specialists
has sprouted, claiming to provide hi- tech facilities, always at an exorbitant
cost.
Remedy:Assisted reproduction should be strictly
monitored, supervised and controlled. It should be cost-effective and subsidised
as part of the family planning programme.
X Gender bias in availability of health care
facilities
A survey of Rajasthan’s leading paediatric hospital
in Jaipur city showed that of all the children brought to the hospital, 70% were
males and 30% females. Of those admitted to the hospital 80% were male. This
bias in an urban, largely educated population calls for serious
introspection
S. G. Kabra, D-102, SDM
Hospital, Jaipur 302 015
Fee- splitting or dichotomy in any shape or form is always unethical. It
means obtaining money from a patient without disclosing in the bill that is
submitted, the manner in which it is made up. Should the patient come to know of
the underhand manner in which the doctor has split the fee he received for
professional service, with a practitioner who brought the patient to him, the
patient can institute legal proceedings against the doctor. The offence is
punishable in law.
-
Dr. Rustom N.
Cooper