A three day international conference on the role of health
professionals in human rights was organised by the Centre for Enquiry into
Health and Allied Themes (CEHAT) from November 28 to 30, 1998. "Preventing
violence, caring for survivors, role of the health profession and services in
violence" was inaugurated by Justice VS Malimath, member of the National Human
Rights Commission, who spoke eloquently on the state of human rights in our
country today, and the changes that need to be brought about.
Mr. Adriaan Van Es of the International Federation of Health and Human
Rights Organisation spoke about the work being done by their organisation and
emphasised the need for the human rights organisations all over the world to
work together.
This was followed by a keynote address sent by Mr Jaap A
Walkate, chairman of the Board of Trustees of the UN voluntary fund for victims
of torture, Geneva. Mr Wal kate was unable to attend the conference because the
Indian government denied him a visa. His address spoke mainly of the possible
involvement of physicians in incidents of state violence. He emphasised that
under no circumstances should physicians participate in torture; when called to
examine such victims, physicians should be able to ascertain whether torture has
been inflicted, and treat the victim. They should not abet such torture by
keeping quiet.
Ms. Binoo Sen, member secretary of the National Commission for Women,
addressing the issue of gender-based violence spoke of the need for health
professionals to adopt a pro-active policy that responds to women in distress,
takes care of their health needs and helps link the emotional and physical
effects of violence on women. Also emphasized was the need for the health
community to build linkages so that effective intervention could be made through
support groups and voluntary organisations.
Ms. Ann Sommerville, head the department of medical ethics in the
British Medical Association, spoke briefly about educating practicing doctors
about medical ethics, the link between human rights and medical ethics and the
need to develop global communication systems facilitating an international
network of health professionals, lawyers, patient advocates and human rights
activists
The later sessions were broken up into group discussions. The four main
groups addressed issues of violence against women; state violence; communal
violence and violence against minorities, and health care and response to
violence. During these discussions, Ms. Iris Tetford of the World Health
Organisation spoke passionately about the need to see violence against women as
a public health priority. She also discussed the 1996 World Health Assembly
resolution formulating a scientifically-based plan of action for the prevention
of violence.
Mr Arvind Tiwari of the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI)
spoke of the CHRI’s ongoing programmes and highlighted the role of medical
officials and paramedical staff in respecting the human rights of incarcerated
prisoners, while providing them care and treatment.
Ms Niraj Seth of the Rajiv Gandhi Foundation spoke about mental health
issues of families affected by terrorism, emphasising the importance of
children’s well-being and the need for intervention by mental health
professionals.
Mr James Welsh, coordinator, Amnesty International, London, who was
also unable to attend the conference after he was denied a visa, sent a message
expressing his disappointment. Health professionals in AI have sought respect
for the rights of asylum seekers and refugees, and the proper provision of
medical care to prisoners.
The second day of the conference concentrated on
the current health care facilities and the need for treatment for survivors of
violence.
Mr. Jagdish Sobti of the Communication Centre emphasised the need to
train medical practitioners in the management of victims of torture and violence
and informed the delegates of a new postgraduate course in this subject started
by the Indian Medical Association.
Ms. V Nathanson of the BMA spoke about rehabilitation centres to help
torture survivors and survivors of domestic and other violence. She noted the
importance of navigating hostile political and social environments to ensure the
safe establishment and survival of help centres
Delegates were given two packages: a manual and evidence kit for
examining physician in cases of sexual assault on women, prepared by Dr Lalitha
D’Souza of CEHAT, and a model autopsy protocol for physicians, presented by
Henri Tiphague, Director, Peoples Watch, Tamil Nadu.
On the last day, discussion focused on strategies, research issues and
the need for networking and joint action. Delegates made interesting inputs
regarding national and international policies, the role of health professionals
in treatment and rehabilitation, ethical issues, and the need for more intensive
community level campaigns.
Dr. Simmi Sachdeva,
1208, Nilanjana Bldg, Marve Road, Malad (W), Mumbai 400
064.