|
|
Indian Journal of Medical Ethics Vol IV No 2 April-June 2007 (incorporating Issues in Medical Ethics, cumulative Vol XV No II)
|
| EDITORIAL |
Medical professionals and the organ trade:an unholy alliance  |
Aamir Jafarey, George Thomas, Aasim Ahmad, Sandhya Srinivasan |
52-53 |
|
| ARTICLES |
Drug promotional practices in Mumbai: a qualitative study  |
Nobhojit Roy, Neha Madhiwalla, Sanjay A Pai |
57-61 |
Restructuring medical education  |
Padmaja Samant Mavani |
62-63 |
| |
| COMMENTARY |
Start sensitising medical students  |
Karuna Ramesh |
64-64 |
The importance of patient privacy during a clinical examination  |
Shailaja Tetali |
65-65 |
HIV/AIDS legislation: an opportunity for health care reform  |
Vivek Divan, Kajal Bhardwaj |
66-67 |
Working towards ethical organ transplants  |
Sunil Shroff |
68-69 |
| |
| INTERNATIONAL ETHICS |
Deceased-donor kidney transplantation in Iran: trends, barriers and opportunities  |
Behzad Einollahi, Mohammad-Hossein Nourbala, Saeid Bahaeloo-Horeh, Shervin Assari, Mahboob Lessan-Pezeshki, Naser Simforoosh |
70-72 |
The importance of "throwing money at" the problem of global health  |
Michael J Selgelid |
73-75 |
| |
| CASE STUDY |
Ethics in nutrition intervention research  |
|
76-77 |
Response: the study served no purpose  |
V Raman Kutty |
78-78 |
Response: an extremely cynical study  |
Veena Shatrugna |
79-80 |
Response: the study was unjustified and fallacious  |
GD Ravindran |
81-81 |
Response: research ethics involves continuous learning  |
Richard A Cash |
82-83 |
| |
| DOCUMENT |
The World Medical Association statement on HIV/AIDS and the medical profession  |
|
84-86 |
| |
| SELECTED SUMMARY |
The social hierarchy of health  |
Bashir Mamdani |
87-89 |
|
| BOOK REVIEWS |
Outsourcing clinical trials  |
Sanjay A Pai |
90-90 |
The dawn of a new dysgenics  |
Mohan Rao |
91-91 |
| |
| FILM REVIEW |
Taking on the taboos  |
Harshal Pandve |
92-92 |
|
BOOKS IN BRIEF  |
43-43 |
FROM OTHER JOURNALS  |
94-96 |
CORRESPONDENCE  |
97-98 |
| The World Social Forum statement on the Global Polio Eradication Initiative The Second World Social Forum on Health, January 20-25, 2007, condemns the World Health Organisation's lack of transparency in acknowledging the failure of the Global Polio Eradication Initiative strategy and instead - identifying a few low-income countries as scapegoats;
- subjecting the children of these countries to an unprecedentedly high number of Oral Polio Vaccine (OPV) through the pulse polio rounds with no concern for its negative impact, and
- using monovalent OPV, an untested vaccine, without informed consent.
While the WSF on Health acknowledges the place of OPV in the overall immunisation programme as part of integrated public health services, the strategy of intensive pulse polio rounds has had a detrimental fragmenting effect on the already weak public health systems in low-income countries. We demand an independent review of the Global Polio Eradication strategy with due consideration to the relevant epidemiology and different countries' health care priorities. Medico Friend Circle (India) Jan Swasthya Abhiyan (India) People's Health Movement and World Social Forum on Health January 24, 2007 Nairobi, Kenya
| | PUBLISHING DETAILS Form IV (See Rule 8) - Place of Publication : Forum for Medical Ethics Society, 0-18, "Bhavna",
Veer Savarkar Marg, Prabhadevi Mumbai 400025. - Periodicity : Quarterly
- Printer's name : Dr Arun Bal Nationality : Indian Address : Flat 6, Mallika, Makrand Housing Society, VS Marg, Mahim, Mumbai 400 016.
- Publisher's name : Dr Arun Bal Nationality : Indian Address : Flat 6, Mallika, Makrand Housing Society, SVS Marg, Mahim, Mumbai 400 016.
- Editor's name : Dr George Thomas Nationality : Indian Address: 114J Rostrevor Garden, Teynampet, Chennai 600 018
|
WHAT SHOULD WE DO ABOUT THE ORGAN TRANSPLANT BUSINESS?
CAN WE REGULATE THE ORGAN BUSINESS
|
Reports that women survivors of the tsunami are being recruited as organ “donors” for the kidney transplant industry in Tamil Nadu have brought the kidney trade back into the limelight. At the same time, Pakistan is in the midst of bringing in an ordinance intended to prevent organ sale and promote a cadaveric transplant programme. The editorial looks at pressures driving the industry and loopholes in the law to regulate it. A comment notes that two
central issues need to be addressed: the effectiveness in implementing the current law, and the financial compulsions that make people donate their organs. An article from Iran discusses the government-regulated system
for organ donation that provides compensation to donors, and calls for the development of a strong cadaveric programme.
A qualitative study on the range of promotional practices influencing drug usage in Mumbai provided a picture of what might be described as an unholy alliance between drug manufacturers, chemists and doctors. The study is
reported in this issue.
An article looks at instances of dysfunctional behaviour in doctors and their causes, and discusses programmes that help doctors deal with stress, work with diverse populations and improve their communication skills.
“HIV/AIDS is global pandemic that has created unprecedented challenges for physicians and health infrastructures,” notes the World Medical Association statement on HIV/AIDS and the medical profession. In India, health infrastructures are sorely tested by and professional associations have not addressed these challenges. We carry in this issue the WMA’s statement on the subject, covering the rights and responsibilities of health care professionals, institutions and medical associations. The authors of a draft bill on HIV/AIDS discuss the need for this legislation and the issues it covers.
The case study describes a study conducted in the early 1970s in which researchers exploring the interaction between malnutrition and infections in children decided to locate groups with a high prevalence of malnutrition and
common infections and compare the relative impacts of health care, nutrition, both or neither. Was the control group justified? We carry responses giving different perspectives on this dilemma.
|
|
|