Journal of the Forum for Medical Ethics Society Since 1993

Home | Current issue | Archives | Table of Contents | About us | Contact us | Links

Current Issue
Vol IX No. 1
Jan - Mar 2012


Recent Issues



Indian Journal of Medical Ethics Vol V No 1 Jan-Mar 2008 (incorporating Issues in Medical Ethics, cumulative Vol XVI No I)
 
EDITORIAL
The Thorat Committee Report and the good doctor  PDF George Thomas 2-3
Medical tourism in India: winners and losers  PDF Amit Sen Gupta 4-5
 
INTERVIEW
Trade secrets from a sperm bank in India  PDF Jyotsna Agnihotri Gupta 9-12
 
COMMENTS
Comment on 'Trade secrets from a sperm bank in India'  PDF Manisha Gupte 13-14
Stem cell transplantation in India: tall claims, questionable ethics  PDF Sunil K Pandya 15-17
Medical ethics education in India  PDF G D Ravindran 18-19
Black money in white coats: whither medical ethics?  PDF Subrata Chattopadhyay 20-21
 
RESEARCH ETHICS
Fieldwork and social science research ethics  PDF Qudsiya Contractor 22-23
 
INTERNATIONAL ETHICS
Therapeutic drug use in Bangladesh: policy versus practice  PDF Mohammad Saidul Islam 24-25
The informed consent status for surgery patients in eastern Turkey: a cross-sectional study  PDF Mucahit Egri
Osman Celbis
Mehmet Karaca
Bora Ozdemir Ahmet Nezih Kok
26-28
 
NATIONAL BIOETHICS CONFERENCE 2007
Bioethics and ayurveda  PDF M S Valiathan 29-30
Medicine, ethics and the law  PDF N R Madhava Menon 31-33
Conference report  PDF Sridevi Seetharam 34-36
Comments from participants  PDF 37-39
 
SELECTED SUMMARY
When a doctor makes a mistake  PDF Bashir Mamdani 40-41
 
BOOK REVIEW
"Is that a fact?" Medical history revisited  PDF Sanjay A Pai 42-42
 
FILM REVIEW
Heaven on earth?  PDF Neha Madhiwalla 43-43
 
FROM THE PRESS  PDF 6-8
BOOKS IN BRIEF  PDF 44-44
FROM OTHER JOURNALS   PDF 45-47
CORRESPONDENCE  PDF 48-49

TRADE SECRETS OF A SPERM BANK


About difficult choices

The character of the medical profession, the manner in which medicine  is practised today and the direction of healthcare are shaped by our  environment with all its inequities of caste, class and gender. This character,  this manner and this direction are reinforced by the messages conveyed in the  medical education system, by the incentives of the new economic policies and  by the actions - or inaction - of regulatory authorities.

Such an understanding is expressed in various ways in this issue. An editorial  writer comments on the Sukhdeo Thorat Committee report documenting  faculty inaction against caste-based harassment of students in the All India  Institute of Medical Sciences. That the caste and other inequities reinforced in  medical school are expressed in medical practice is illustrated in an interview  with the director of a sperm bank; parents demand - and doctors arrange - sperm of the desired caste and economic background. 

The second editorial describes how the inequities in this environment are  reinforced by the government. As private medical care grows it seeks foreign  markets; hence the policy to promote "medical tourism" with tax breaks and other  incentives - even as the vast majority of poor Indians have no access to healthcare.

Stem cell "therapy" is another example of an industry promoted by the  government policy of turning a blind eye to its unregulated proliferation.  A commentary writer documents the unjustified claims that prompt the  desperate to spend their life savings in the hope of being cured of a serious  disease. Doctors undertake experiments with neither scientific basis nor  ethical clearance in the name of treatment.

Regulatory authorities indicate their inability - or unwillingness - to take  action against unethical practices. Another commentary writer describing his  encounters with corruption in medical practice points out that corruption has  infiltrated the profession at every level, including those agencies meant to  enforce ethical practice. Those who benefit from the existing system - within  medical practice and in society in general - have every interest in maintaining  the current state of affairs.

More than 500 health professionals, researchers, policy makers and students  attended the Indian Journal of Medical Ethics Second National Bioethics  Conference in Bangalore. We carry a report on the conference and comments  from participants.




Submit articles | Guidelines for submission | Editorial Board | Opportunities | Subscribe | Disclaimer
© Indian Journal of Medical Ethics