Journal of the Forum for Medical Ethics Society Since 1993

Home | Current issue | Archives | Table of Contents | About us | Contact us | Links

Current Issue
Vol IX No. 1
Jan - Mar 2012


Recent Issues



Click here for the PDF version of this Issue
Indian Journal of Medical Ethics Vol VII No. 2 April-June 2010
EDITORIAL
Gifts to doctors, scientific information and the credibility gap in the Medical Council of India  PDF George Thomas 68-69
The new rural doctor: qualified quack or appropriate healthcare provider?  PDF Joe Varghese 70-72

ARTICLES
Is there an elephant in the room? Boundary violations in the doctor-patient relationship in India  PDF Sunita Simon Kurpad
Tanya Machado
R B Galgali
76-81
Patenting of human genetic material v. bioethics: revisiting the case of John Moore v. Regents of the University of California  PDF Nithya Narayanan 82-89
Informed consent: a survey of general dental practitioners in Belgaum city  PDF Vijayalakshmi S Kotrashetti
Alka D Kale
Mamata Hebbal
Seema R Hallikeremath
90-94

COMMENTS
Medical negligence: need for balanced approach   PDF NR Madhava Menon 95-96
Patent dispute: Delhi High Court gives a boost to access to affordable medicines   PDF Leena Menghaney 97-100
Informed consent is a moral imperative   PDF Aamir Jafarey
Farhat Moazam
101-103
Issues related to non-heart-beating organ donation   PDF Rajesh Bardale 104-106
Are we ready for non-heart-beating organ donation in India?   PDF Sanjay Nagral 106-107

LAW AND ETHICS
Legal changes towards justice for sexual assault victims   PDF N Jagadeesh 108-112

SELECTED SUMMARY
How does a nation decide what healthcare to pay for?   PDF Sridhar Srikantiah 115-116

REVIEWS
Book review:Morality is natural - but difficult   PDF Sunil K Pandya 117-118
The difficulty of being good:on the subtle art of dharma,Gurcharan Das
Book review:Matters of life and death.Bioethics:an introduction to the history,methods and practice,   PDF Geeta Balakrishnan 118-119
edited by Nancy S Jecker,Albert R Jonsen,Robert A Pearlman
Film review:Warding off the evil eye.Matti o manush(The soil and the people)   PDF Shobha Mocherla 119-120
Directed by Sisir Sahana


FROM THE PRESS   PDF 73-75
MEETING REPORT   PDF 113-114
FROM OTHER JOURNALS   PDF 121-123
LETTERS   PDF 124-126
CLINICAL TRIALS WATCH   PDF 127-129

GIFTS TO DOCTORS AND THE CREDIBILITY GAP IN THE MCI


Ethics and the law

Writers in this issue of the journal have a lot to say about the role that the law and regulatory bodies can and do play in supporting ethics at various levels. An editorial speculates on whether the Medical Council of India's ban on doctors receiving gifts from the drug industry has any meaning given the poor credibility of this institution. Another editorial asks whether the MCI's rural doctors scheme will result in more equitable access to healthcare. A senior jurist comments on the recent Supreme Court judgment on criminal medical negligence and its implications for medical practice. An activist comments on the legal battle launched by Bayer to block generic drug production, and the implications for people's right to affordable medicines. An article discusses laws relevant to decisions on patenting of human genetic material.

A survey of boundary violations in the doctor-patient relationship found enough evidence that sexual and nonsexual boundary violations occur in India, and this is a matter that needs urgent attention. Professional bodies need to implement existing guidelines on this subject.

With this issue we start a regular column, Ethics and the Law. In the first column, a forensic doctor presents an overview of laws applicable to sexual assault cases and amendments in these laws as they relate to the responsibilities of healthcare providers. We welcome submissions to this column.

But the law is not enough, as the writers commenting on a survey of informed consent point out. Obtaining informed consent for treatment is not about getting a patient to sign a form that protects the doctor from liability; consent is not a legal requirement but an ethical imperative. They write: "We do not wish to discount the protective role of laws, when they are applicable and accessible to all citizens, as external checks. However, we continue to believe that the best protection for patients remains ethical healthcare professionals through an internal professional morality."




Submit articles | Guidelines for submission | Editorial Board | Opportunities | Subscribe | Disclaimer
© Indian Journal of Medical Ethics