Journal of the Forum for Medical Ethics Society Since 1993

Home | Current issue | Archives | Table of Contents | About us | Contact us | Links

Current Issue
Vol IX No. 1
Jan - Mar 2012


Recent Issues



Click here for the PDF version of this Issue
Indian Journal of Medical Ethics Vol VIII No. 4, October - December 2011
EDITORIALS
Institutional ethics committees: critical gaps  PDF George Thomas 200-201
Evidence-based medicine: can the evidence be trusted?  PDF Prathap Tharyan 201-207
ARTICLES
A study of warning letters issued to clinical investigators and institutional review boards by the United States Food and Drug Administration  PDF NJ Gogtay
BM Doshi
S Kannan
U Thatte
211-214
Survey of ethics committee protocol approval letters: compliance with Schedule Y / ICMR Guidelines 2006  PDF Santosh R Taur
Sandeep B Bavdekar
Urmila M Thatte
214-216
Considering ethics in community eye health planning: perspectives from an existing model  PDF Usha Raman
Sethu Sheeladevi
216-223
Impact of UNCRPD on the status of persons with disabilities  PDF Smitha Nizar 223-229
COMMENTS
Bringing back Aristotle  PDF John Saunders 230-233
Some observations on the World Development Report 2011: conflict, security and development  PDF Leena V Gangolli 234-236
Planning and response to the influenza A (H1N1) pandemic: ethics, equity and justice  PDF Mahesh Devnani
Anil Kumar Gupta
Bharti Devnani
237-240
Free medical care and consumer protection   PDF Aniket Deepak Agrawal
Arunabha Banerjee
240-242
Commentary: implicit contract with providing agencies, not with care providers  PDF Vineesh Mathur 243-243
The ethics of live surgery: an ongoing debate  PDF Sunil Morekar 244-245
Commentary: live telecast surgery on shaky ground  PDF Jaydeep Palep 245-245
Reflections on the High Court's dismissal of the 'TISS rape case'  PDF Sana Contractor
on behalf of the
CEHAT team
on violence against women
246-247
CASE STUDY
When the patient's family refuses care: a practical ethical dilemma  PDF Vijay Gopichandran
Rakhal Gaitonde
248-249
Response: caught between two world views  PDF Roopa Devadasan 249-251
MEDICAL STUDENTS SPEAK
Can we make our hospitals more patient-friendly?  PDF Yogesh S Kumar 252-252
SELECTED SUMMARY
Ethics in cluster randomised trials: a grey zone   PDF Anant Bhan 253-254
REVIEWS
Plan for ethics education: WHO guide for teaching medical ethics in the South-East Asian Region  PDF GD Ravindran 255-255
Cursed goddess:Jogwa  PDF Vijaylakshmi Kathawate 256-256
DOCUMENT
Rijeka Declaration on the future of bioethics   PDF   260-260
   
FROM THE PRESS  PDF 208-210
FROM OTHER JOURNALS   PDF 257-259
LETTERS  PDF 261-263

The importance of questions



Are our efforts to be ethical hampered by a myopic vision? Does ethical behaviour mean doing what is permissible, or what is good? Such questions are rarely asked as most of us take ethics as a given. A comment in this issue argues for a fresh emphasis on the philosophy of virtue ethics, going beyond the framework of Principlism, and suggests a combined approach for greater effectiveness. This need for a broader vision is also felt by young physicians in a tribal setting, faced with a challenge to their own sense of ethical duty. A commentator analyses the responsibility of the care giver in such a situation, and suggests that there is a need to step off the beaten track and into the patient’s worldview.

Two authors look critically at common assumptions - that a disabled child should be prevented from being born, or that patients receiving free treatment have no rights as consumers - and make us question them. Another expresses his doubts about the ethical value of modern teaching tools. Yet another comments on the ethical considerations related to influenza pandemic planning and response during the influenza A H1N1virus pandemic.

Getting down to brass tacks, we have a group of researchers looking at features of the regulatory systems for monitoring clinical research bodies in the US; while another group studies the compliance of ethics committees with the official guidelines. An article analyses ethical issues in the design and implementation of public health interventions.

Finally, is research being derailed both by vested interests and a lack of clarity? One of our editorials exposes some serious lacunae in the formation and conduct of institutional ethics committees, which could completely negate the purpose of their existence. Another explores the numerous frightening ways in which the evidence provided by clinical trials can be distorted, and calls upon the scientific community to reclaim the research agenda.




Submit articles | Guidelines for submission | Editorial Board | Opportunities | Subscribe | Disclaimer
© Indian Journal of Medical Ethics